Visa resultat

Complex Systems Seminar Series 2009-2010, FFR141

1. What is your overall impression of the seminar series course?

very good»		4		66%
good»		1		16%
so and so»		1		16%
bad»		0		0%
really bad»		0		0%
No opinion»		0

Genomsnitt: 1.5

- EFwsjY <a href="http://taagysdgetev.com/">taagysdgetev</a>, [url=http://rviorzymmajs.com/]rviorzymmajs[/url], [link=http://hlgajliptyxi.com/]hlgajliptyxi[/link], http://gteogusieitv.com/» (very good)
- I liked listening to the wide spectrum of applications and the original ideas presented. » (very good)
- 52l0J5 <a href="http://demuazhwwewb.com/">demuazhwwewb</a>, [url=http://jtvdorlmrrij.com/]jtvdorlmrrij[/url], [link=http://ivekbqrshgpw.com/]ivekbqrshgpw[/link], http://kogrtbbltgan.com/» (very good)
- "So and so" is the time average. The first half was really a waste of time, with the new structure it is actually quite good.» (so and so)

2. Did you find the seminars interesting

yes, almost all of them where interesting»		1		16%
yes, most of them where interesting»		1		16%
about half of the seminars where interesting»		2		33%
no, there where only a few seminars that I found interesting»		2		33%
really bad»		0		0%
No opinion»		0

Genomsnitt: 2.83

- EFwsjY <a href="http://taagysdgetev.com/">taagysdgetev</a>, [url=http://rviorzymmajs.com/]rviorzymmajs[/url], [link=http://hlgajliptyxi.com/]hlgajliptyxi[/link], http://gteogusieitv.com/» (yes, almost all of them where interesting)
- I think that many presentations could"ve covered more interesting subjects. » (about half of the seminars where interesting)
- it may be good to be bit more restrictive on the subjects allowed. Now it feels like some presenters discover that their subject isn"t very "complex systems" when they are standing in front of the class.» (about half of the seminars where interesting)
- Many of the _topics_ are interesting, only a few of the talks are interesting.» (no, there where only a few seminars that I found interesting)
- 52l0J5 <a href="http://demuazhwwewb.com/">demuazhwwewb</a>, [url=http://jtvdorlmrrij.com/]jtvdorlmrrij[/url], [link=http://ivekbqrshgpw.com/]ivekbqrshgpw[/link], http://kogrtbbltgan.com/» (no, there where only a few seminars that I found interesting)

3. What did you think about sending in the presentation prior to giving your seminar?

(på denna fråga var det möjligt att välja flera svarsalternativ)

It was good because I (and others) had to prepare»		3		42%
It was good because I got some feedback»		4		57%
Not good because it took too much time»		0		0%
It would have been good if I had gotten better feedback»		0		0%
I think the deadline should have been earlier»		0		0%
No opinion»		0

- Only drawback is that it communicates an assumption that everyone wants to use slides as the basis for their presentation, and/or that the slides on their own should convey the message of your presentation, which is not at all a good use of slides (imho)» ()
- EFwsjY <a href="http://taagysdgetev.com/">taagysdgetev</a>, [url=http://rviorzymmajs.com/]rviorzymmajs[/url], [link=http://hlgajliptyxi.com/]hlgajliptyxi[/link], http://gteogusieitv.com/» ()
- Deadlines are good. Makes planning easier.» ()
- Very good, this made me prepare in good time, and thin a lot more about what to say. Also Martin gave me good feedback on what level I should try to aim for.» ()
- 52l0J5 <a href="http://demuazhwwewb.com/">demuazhwwewb</a>, [url=http://jtvdorlmrrij.com/]jtvdorlmrrij[/url], [link=http://ivekbqrshgpw.com/]ivekbqrshgpw[/link], http://kogrtbbltgan.com/» ()

4. Did you find the meeting with Chalmers Communication Center helpful?

Yes very much so»		1		20%
Yes to some extent»		2		40%
Not so much»		0		0%
Not at all»		2		40%

Genomsnitt: 2.6

- Did not attend. We did for the bachelor thesis projects though and were not very impressed. Heard others say otherwise though so it might be very dependent on which tutor you get assigned..» (?)
- They really helped me improve my presentation, specially the slides. This should be pressed even harder next year, everyone could benefit from going there.» (Yes very much so)
- EFwsjY <a href="http://taagysdgetev.com/">taagysdgetev</a>, [url=http://rviorzymmajs.com/]rviorzymmajs[/url], [link=http://hlgajliptyxi.com/]hlgajliptyxi[/link], http://gteogusieitv.com/» (Yes to some extent)
- 52l0J5 <a href="http://demuazhwwewb.com/">demuazhwwewb</a>, [url=http://jtvdorlmrrij.com/]jtvdorlmrrij[/url], [link=http://ivekbqrshgpw.com/]ivekbqrshgpw[/link], http://kogrtbbltgan.com/» (Yes to some extent)
- This things always has a tendency to be on the elementary school level. It more or less adds nothing of value.» (Not at all)
- I scheduled a meeting, but nobody appeared. I really don"t think this should be mandatory.» (Not at all)

5. How did you experience the seminar that you gave?

(på denna fråga var det möjligt att välja flera svarsalternativ)

I think it was good practice»		3		42%
I think the teacher interrupted too much»		0		0%
I liked the interruptions and the discussions»		4		57%
There was too little discussions»		0		0%
No opinion»		0

- This is the whole point of the course and why it should be kept. There is way too few opportunities to present something substantial during the five (5) years in Chalmers.» ()
- Most of the interruptions were good, but sometimes some of the questions Martin asks is a bit far-fetched and not so relevant. Generally his philosophical questions/comments are really good and the technical ones varied in quality.» ()
- EFwsjY <a href="http://taagysdgetev.com/">taagysdgetev</a>, [url=http://rviorzymmajs.com/]rviorzymmajs[/url], [link=http://hlgajliptyxi.com/]hlgajliptyxi[/link], http://gteogusieitv.com/» ()
- I think it was great that I could combine personal interest (a subject of my own choice) with course work.» ()
- Unfortunately Martin wasn"t there and the substitute wasn"t as good at starting the discussion as him. But I really felt I learned much giving my first presentation in English.» ()
- 52l0J5 <a href="http://demuazhwwewb.com/">demuazhwwewb</a>, [url=http://jtvdorlmrrij.com/]jtvdorlmrrij[/url], [link=http://ivekbqrshgpw.com/]ivekbqrshgpw[/link], http://kogrtbbltgan.com/» ()

6. Did you appreciate the personal feedback after your presentation from the panel and the lecturer?

6 svarande

yes»		6		100%
no»		0		0%
I did not get any feedback»		0

Genomsnitt: 1

- Yes. My impression is that Martin always makes an effort to find some opinions on everything. It is genarally a good thing, but please think about being clear on what is objective and subjective criticism.» (yes)
- Only feedback from Martin but it was good, perhaps it could have been a bit more critical (commenting on negative aspects more).» (yes)
- EFwsjY <a href="http://taagysdgetev.com/">taagysdgetev</a>, [url=http://rviorzymmajs.com/]rviorzymmajs[/url], [link=http://hlgajliptyxi.com/]hlgajliptyxi[/link], http://gteogusieitv.com/» (yes)
- I liked the constructive criticism.» (yes)
- The feedback from the panel and the teacher was better than that from the audience, and I got some very good advice to think about.» (yes)
- 52l0J5 <a href="http://demuazhwwewb.com/">demuazhwwewb</a>, [url=http://jtvdorlmrrij.com/]jtvdorlmrrij[/url], [link=http://ivekbqrshgpw.com/]ivekbqrshgpw[/link], http://kogrtbbltgan.com/» (yes)

7. Did you appreciate the feedback from the audience?

6 svarande

Yes it was very helpful and will improve future presentation»		1		25%
Yes it was somewhat useful»		1		25%
It was OK but nothing new»		0		0%
I did not like the feedback»		2		50%
I found the feedback insulting and not truthful»		0		0%
I presented in the fall and did not get any feedback»		2

Genomsnitt: 2.75

- EFwsjY <a href="http://taagysdgetev.com/">taagysdgetev</a>, [url=http://rviorzymmajs.com/]rviorzymmajs[/url], [link=http://hlgajliptyxi.com/]hlgajliptyxi[/link], http://gteogusieitv.com/» (I did not like the feedback)
- 52l0J5 <a href="http://demuazhwwewb.com/">demuazhwwewb</a>, [url=http://jtvdorlmrrij.com/]jtvdorlmrrij[/url], [link=http://ivekbqrshgpw.com/]ivekbqrshgpw[/link], http://kogrtbbltgan.com/» (I did not like the feedback)

8. How did you find Martin as a teacher?

very god»		4		66%
good»		1		16%
so and so»		0		0%
bad»		1		16%
really bad»		0		0%
No opinion»		0

Genomsnitt: 1.66

- The usefulness of the course rests with having Martin as a teacher. I can imaginge few previous teachers I"ve had who could make this course as good as it should be (and is).» (very god)
- EFwsjY <a href="http://taagysdgetev.com/">taagysdgetev</a>, [url=http://rviorzymmajs.com/]rviorzymmajs[/url], [link=http://hlgajliptyxi.com/]hlgajliptyxi[/link], http://gteogusieitv.com/» (very god)
- Martins questions really makes you focus on the weak points in your presentation and think carefully about the subject. I also felt that in the end of the course I myself started to ask the same types of questions every time I hear a presentation. Good at starting everybody thinking.» (very god)
- "very god" would maybe be an exaggeration ,) Not very much "teaching" to tell from, but Martin seems to have a broad knowledge and uses it to pose tricky questions, which is stimulating the seminar.» (good)
- 52l0J5 <a href="http://demuazhwwewb.com/">demuazhwwewb</a>, [url=http://jtvdorlmrrij.com/]jtvdorlmrrij[/url], [link=http://ivekbqrshgpw.com/]ivekbqrshgpw[/link], http://kogrtbbltgan.com/» (bad)

9. How did you find Claes as a teacher?

very god»		1		16%
good»		1		16%
so and so»		1		16%
bad»		3		50%
really bad»		0		0%
No opinion»		0

Genomsnitt: 3

- EFwsjY <a href="http://taagysdgetev.com/">taagysdgetev</a>, [url=http://rviorzymmajs.com/]rviorzymmajs[/url], [link=http://hlgajliptyxi.com/]hlgajliptyxi[/link], http://gteogusieitv.com/» (good)
- 52l0J5 <a href="http://demuazhwwewb.com/">demuazhwwewb</a>, [url=http://jtvdorlmrrij.com/]jtvdorlmrrij[/url], [link=http://ivekbqrshgpw.com/]ivekbqrshgpw[/link], http://kogrtbbltgan.com/» (so and so)
- This might be unfair as the whole course was very unstructured at the time when Claes was teaching, but I didn"t really see any appreciable moderating of anything.» (bad)
- Not the same clear questions as Martin. Somewhat unclear reasoning when he tries to ask a question.» (bad)

10. Did you feel that the changes made for the spring semester improved the class?

Yes very much»		2		33%
Yes»		3		50%
Not really»		1		16%
The opposite»		0		0%

Genomsnitt: 1.83

- Slightly better» (Yes)
- I would remove the panel. Rest is good.» (Yes)
- 52l0J5 <a href="http://demuazhwwewb.com/">demuazhwwewb</a>, [url=http://jtvdorlmrrij.com/]jtvdorlmrrij[/url], [link=http://ivekbqrshgpw.com/]ivekbqrshgpw[/link], http://kogrtbbltgan.com/» (Yes)
- EFwsjY <a href="http://taagysdgetev.com/">taagysdgetev</a>, [url=http://rviorzymmajs.com/]rviorzymmajs[/url], [link=http://hlgajliptyxi.com/]hlgajliptyxi[/link], http://gteogusieitv.com/» (Not really)

11. Other comments and suggestions for next year (other than the changes we have discussed in class)?